//

Blogpoll Preliminary Ballot: Week 6

Rank Team Delta
1 Oklahoma
2 Alabama
3 Penn State 1
4 Missouri 1
5 Texas
6 LSU
7 Brigham Young 1
8 Georgia 1
9 Florida 1
10 Southern Cal 1
11 Ohio State 1
12 Oklahoma State 1
13 Utah 2
14 Texas Tech 2
15 Vanderbilt 3
16 South Florida 9
17 Illinois 2
18 Virginia Tech 6
19 Kansas 2
20 Boise State 1
21 Michigan State 5
22 Florida State 1
23 Kentucky 3
24 Pittsburgh 2
25 Cincinnati 1

Dropped Out: Auburn (#14), Wisconsin (#20), Fresno State (#22), Wake Forest (#25).

Games Watched (listed in the order I watched them): Middle Tennessee-FAU, Boise State-Lousiana Tech, USF-Pitt, Utah-Oregon State, Cincinnati-Marshall, Michigan State-Iowa, Penn State-Purdue, Michigan-Illinois, Bama-Kentucky, Ohio State-Wisconsin, Missouri-Nebraska, Minnesota-Indiana, Notre Dame-Stanford, UConn-UNC, Texas-Colorado, Miami of Florida-Florida State.

Anything look wrong? Anything I need to justify?

Posted under BlogPoll

Blogpoll Roundtable 4.3

Hosted by Big Red Network.

Q: Of the four presumed national title contenders to go down this past week–USC, Florida, Georgia, Wisconsin–which team has the best chance to get back in the race by the end of the year?

I’m not sure Wisconsin really counted as a national title contender going in, so the loss to Michigan seems to keep them out for sure, unless they completely run roughshod over the remainder of their schedule.
Florida and USC both lost to vastly inferior opponents, and the Gators had the added “benefit” of doing it on their home field. The Gators, however, face a schedule that is sure to give them the opportunity for several more quality wins over the course of the season. USC, on the other hand, is playing in the relatively weak PAC-10. Only their run of “dominance” (which really seems to have ended a couple years ago) that has voters constantly voting them high can possibly keep them in… and of course they destroyed former #2 Ohio State.
Georgia got completely housed in its home stadium, but at least they lost to a team that was previously undefeated, and is now likely to be the #1 or #2 team in the country by any reasonable standard. The SEC schedule (and a possibly-quality OOC win against Arizona State on the road), including a championship game if they get that far, more than gives them the opportunity to work their way back into the MNC game – assuming Bama stumbles somewhere along the way. 

Q: But what does this mean for Ohio State? Are they back in?

They are back in, but only in the sense that it brings USC, Georgia, and Florida one step closer to having two losses this early in the season. Ohio State will have to be a full game better than any of those teams to make it back to the championship. It may not be fair for the Buckeyes, but in the world of college football, perception is everything, and getting killed in front of a national audience in their last three big out-of-conference games makes the Buckeyes comparatively weak.
Q: Did the week that was open the door for any of the undefeateds out of some of the non-BCS conferences like the Mountain West or the Big East? (Yup, that’s a cheap shot. Thanks, Virginia Tech for not allowing me to make it about the ACC.)
The door is theoretically open, but BYU or Utah would have to perform well against their non-conference competition (Utah has its last chance against an Oregon State team that just thoroughly dominated USC, and BYU’s last effort will be against… Utah State) AND beat the other team, on top of running the conference table. BYU’s non-conference run was less impressive, so Utah probably has a better chance to make it to the MNC game.
However, like Ohio State, these two teams are playing at a major disadvantage in terms if perception. BYU has a little more histroy on its side, but Utah’s season would be more impressive if they finished undefeated. Either way, it will require that no BCS-conference team is undefeated, and more likely that there are very few legimiate contenders with only one loss.

Posted under Analysis, BlogPoll

Comments Off on Blogpoll Roundtable 4.3

Tags: ,

Blogpoll Final Ballot: Week 5

Rank Team Delta
1 Oklahoma 1
2 Alabama 15
3 Missouri 5
4 Penn State 3
5 Texas
6 LSU
7 South Florida 5
8 Brigham Young 3
9 Georgia 5
10 Florida 7
11 Southern Cal 10
12 Ohio State 2
13 Oklahoma State
14 Auburn
15 Utah 1
16 Texas Tech 1
17 Kansas 1
18 Vanderbilt 5
19 Illinois 3
20 Wisconsin 11
21 Boise State 3
22 Fresno State 1
23 Florida State 3
24 Virginia Tech 2
25 Wake Forest 6

Dropped Out: Miami (Florida) (#20), Clemson (#25).

Changes from Draft: Bama moves over LSU because their resume is much more impressive so far, same with Mizzou over Texas. I moved Penn State up some because I simply think they’re good, not necessarily because their competition has been all that good (though they haven’t let anyone come close yet). Georgia, Florida, Ohio State, and USC moved within proximity of each other, and they are ranked as they are because USC’s loss was embarrassing, but they beat OSU, and because Georgia’s loss was embarrassing, but Bama looks right now like a really good team. Illinois moves down slightly because they do have two losses, but both are to top teams. Wisconsin is back in, because their omission was nothing more than an oversight by me.

I’m still not enamored with my ballot. Next week, I’m going to start phasing out the “hybrid” and go more towards straight-up resume ranking.

Posted under BlogPoll

Blogpoll Preliminary Ballot: Week 5

Rank Team Delta
1 Oklahoma 1
2 LSU 4
3 Alabama 14
4 Texas 1
5 Missouri 3
6 Penn State 1
7 Brigham Young 4
8 South Florida 4
9 Florida 6
10 Southern Cal 9
11 Oklahoma State 2
12 Auburn 2
13 Ohio State 3
14 Texas Tech 1
15 Georgia 11
16 Utah
17 Kansas 1
18 Illinois 4
19 Vanderbilt 4
20 Boise State 4
21 Fresno State
22 Florida State 4
23 Virginia Tech 3
24 Wake Forest 5
25 Northwestern 1

Dropped Out: Wisconsin (#9), Miami (Florida) (#20), Clemson (#25).

Games Watched: USC-Oregon State, much of Louisville-UConn, Ohio State-Minnesota, First half of Michigan State-Indiana, Most of UMiami-UNC, Michigan-Wisconsin (live only), A tiny portion of Oklahoma-TCU, Georgia-Alabama, Penn State-Illinois. Less than usual because the Michigan game wiped me out. Plus I forgot to DVR things.

Yeah, so I’m not particularly enthused about this ballot. Plus, I didn’t get a chance to watch as many games as I would have liked. So, let me have it, I know I deserve it this week.

Posted under BlogPoll

Blogpoll Final Ballot: Week 4

Rank Team Delta
1 Southern Cal
2 Oklahoma
3 Florida
4 Georgia
5 Texas
6 LSU
7 Penn State
8 Missouri
9 Wisconsin
10 Ohio State
11 Brigham Young 3
12 South Florida 1
13 Oklahoma State 1
14 Auburn 1
15 Texas Tech 2
16 Utah
17 Alabama 3
18 Kansas 1
19 Wake Forest 2
20 Miami (Florida) 4
21 Fresno State 2
22 Illinois 3
23 Vanderbilt 3
24 Boise State 2
25 Clemson 1

Dropped Out: East Carolina (#11), Oregon (#18), West Virginia (#22).

Changes: Nothing.

Reasoning: I still don’t think OSU should be much lower than 10th. Sure, they got housed by USC, but point out more than 5-6 teams that probably wouldn’t, and I’ll give you $100. Of course, USC is bound to slip up against an inferior opponent, but that’s the ropes, I guess. The reason ECU dropped out isn’t because they lost one game, it’s because they lost one game to a team that had previously been among the most pathetic in all the BCS conferences. Other than that, there were no gripes about my rankings.

Posted under BlogPoll

Comments Off on Blogpoll Final Ballot: Week 4

Tags:

Blogpoll Preliminary Ballot: Week 4

Rank Team Delta
1 Southern Cal
2 Oklahoma
3 Florida
4 Georgia
5 Texas
6 LSU
7 Penn State
8 Missouri
9 Wisconsin
10 Ohio State
11 Brigham Young 3
12 South Florida 1
13 Oklahoma State 1
14 Auburn 1
15 Texas Tech 2
16 Utah
17 Alabama 3
18 Kansas 1
19 Wake Forest 2
20 Miami (Florida) 4
21 Fresno State 2
22 Illinois 3
23 Vanderbilt 3
24 Boise State 2
25 Clemson 1
Dropped Out: East Carolina (#11), Oregon (#18), West Virginia (#22).

Games Watched: Louisville-Kansas State, West Virginia-Colorado, the second half of Baylor-UConn, Iowa-Pitt, Ohio State-Troy, the second half of ECU-NC State, most of the fourth quarter of Purdue-CMU, Notre Dame-MSU, Florida-Tennessee, much of Florida State-Wake Forest, LSU-Auburn, most of Georgia-Arizona State.

This draft is ridiculously rough, because I haven’t had time to fully digest everything. Comments welcome.

Posted under BlogPoll

Blogpoll Final Ballot: Week 3

Rank Team Delta
1 Southern Cal
2 Oklahoma
3 Florida 1
4 Georgia 1
5 Texas 1
6 LSU 1
7 Penn State 1
8 Missouri 1
9 Wisconsin 1
10 Ohio State 5
11 East Carolina 5
12 Oklahoma State 2
13 South Florida 2
14 Brigham Young 12
15 Auburn 4
16 Utah 1
17 Texas Tech 1
18 Oregon 5
19 Kansas 1
20 Alabama 8
21 Wake Forest 3
22 West Virginia
23 Fresno State 3
24 Miami (Florida) 1
25 Illinois 2

Dropped Out: California (#19), Arizona State (#21).

Changes from Draft: Moved Oklahoma back ahead of Florida, and gave BYU a little bump to account for their shellacking of UCLA.

Posted under BlogPoll

Comments Off on Blogpoll Final Ballot: Week 3

Tags:

Blogpoll Preliminary Ballot: Week 3

Rank Team Delta
1 Southern Cal
2 Florida 2
3 Oklahoma 1
4 Georgia 1
5 Texas 1
6 LSU 1
7 Penn State 1
8 Missouri 1
9 Wisconsin 1
10 Ohio State 5
11 East Carolina 5
12 Oklahoma State 2
13 South Florida 2
14 Auburn 3
15 Utah 2
16 Texas Tech 2
17 Oregon 4
18 Brigham Young 8
19 Kansas 1
20 Alabama 8
21 Wake Forest 3
22 West Virginia
23 Fresno State 3
24 Miami (Florida) 1
25 Illinois 2

Dropped Out: California (#19), Arizona State (#21).

Games watched:
Most of UNC-Rutgers, Kansas-USF, Michigan State-FAU, Iowa-Iowa State, portions of Maryland-Cal, Northwestern-SIU, Michigan-Notre Dame, Most of PSU-Syracuse, portions of UGa-SoCar, Much of Auburn-Miss St, OSU-USC, Most of Oklahoma-Washington, Wisconsin-Fresno St.

I actually have a couple more games on DVR that I’ll watch before submitting my final ballot. I didn’t thoroughly look at last week’s final ballot when I put this together, so there might be a few inconsistencies I have to correct.

Posted under BlogPoll

Blogpoll Final Ballot: Week 2

Rank Team Delta
1 Southern Cal 1
2 Oklahoma 3
3 Georgia 1
4 Florida 1
5 Ohio State 4
6 Texas
7 LSU
8 Penn State 2
9 Missouri 2
10 Wisconsin 1
11 Auburn 1
12 Alabama 2
13 Oregon 2
14 Oklahoma State 3
15 South Florida 2
16 East Carolina 10
17 Utah 1
18 Texas Tech 8
19 California 3
20 Kansas 4
21 Arizona State
22 West Virginia 14
23 Illinois
24 Wake Forest 5
25 Miami (Florida) 1

Dropped Out: South Carolina (#16), Brigham Young (#20), Colorado (#25).

Changes: Dropped OSU a little further down, which doesn’t bother me too much since they’ll have a chance to recover with a win this weekend. Decided I hadn’t previously been harsh enough on West Virginia, and dropped them further. Conversely, East Carolina moved up a couple more spots. I tempered my enthusiasm for Kansas as well.

Posted under BlogPoll

Comments Off on Blogpoll Final Ballot: Week 2

Tags:

Blogpoll Roundtable: Week 2

Didn’t participate last week, but here it is for week 2. Hosted by Braves & Birds.

1. How would you rate your program’s service to you in the first two weeks of the season?

Michigan’s accomplishments are approximately as I expected, but the manner in which they got there is troubling. I can handle a loss to Utah and a Victory over Miami, but I’d really prefer if the offense didn’t look quite so anemic in the process. Hopefully the early-season kinks will be hammered out soon. Alas, there is no guarantee that this team is capable of doing much better, given the talent that they have.

2. How happy are you with your program’s overall scheme? We are in a period in which the spread has become a total obsession in the media. If you’re a fan of a spread team, are you happy with the way your program has implemented it? If you’re a fan of a non-spread team, do you wish that your program would convert to this Xenu of offenses?

Michigan’s schemes look good, but execution errors are killing the offense. The o-line performed better against the RedHawks than they did against Utah, but it still isn’t good enough to get by your average Big Ten defense, and certainly not a team like Ohio State.

Also, I think Steven Threet needs to be named the starting quarterback permanently so at least one of the options can gain confidence. I think if he had a chance to get settled in, Threet would have fewer errors due to being overwhelmed or excited, and it would benefit the team in both the long and short runs.

Defensively, I’m impressed. The linebackers are young (and showing it), and Stevie Brown is a constant liability, but the schemes themselves are working pretty well. Hopefully Brown will be able to put it together mentally a little later in the year, and this defense could start to really dominate.

3. Rate your stadium’s cleanliness and menu options.

I rarely use any portion of Michigan Stadium that isn’t my seat or the exit. The seats are same as always, but the mode of egress from the Stadium is obnoxious and impossible to accomplish in fewer than 20-ish minutes. I’m sure the bathrooms are rockin’ pisswall as well as they always have.

4. As an incentive to provide your valued feedback, you will be entered into a drawing for exciting prizes! What one prize would you like for your program?

Terrelle Pryor, plz.

5. Since we’re all about choices, take one of the following two options for entertainment’s sake:

a. What’s your most memorable experience involving a comment card?

b. If your program were a casual dining chain, which one would it be? Yes, this is a tricky question because the defining characteristic of a casual dining chain is its sameness. No one said this Roundtable would be easy. Bonus points if you can make a compelling case that your program is Chotchkie’s or Flingers.

Something that is undergoing a radical change with some growing pains, that’s for sure. Maybe a Long John Silver’s that’s being transformed into, say, a Friday’s. In the long run, it will be an improvement (though maybe Friday’s isn’t the best example), but for now, they’re trying to use crappy fried fish as ingredients in everything.

Posted under Analysis, BlogPoll

Comments Off on Blogpoll Roundtable: Week 2

Tags: ,